Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Geoff Levin's avatar

I have visited Great Britain and plan to return there. I was member of Scientology for almost 50 years.

While in the UK I would if my schedule permits participate in a protest and follow the guidelines set out by the protesters and council.

The protests are necessary to expose the continued abuse by the church of its staff and unfounded attacks and defamation of ex-members and social media reporters exposing the crimes of the church of Scientology.

Politico's avatar

Hi Alex - I have worked in politics in the US for many years and although I am unfamiliar with free speech laws in the UK, there are a few points I would raise for your consideration:

Acceptance of this 'voluntary code of conduct' implies that you are conceding that there has been some type of misconduct on the part of the protestors that needs to be prevented, despite the assertion here that you have adhered to many of these guidelines already. ("The Council accepts that some of these items already appear on your protest website (iasprotest.com ), and/or reflect protesters’ practices during recent events at Church premises.")

The notion of requiring you to adhere to a "voluntary" code of conduct is counterintuitive and would be unenforceable. It's voluntary, not required. And extremely problematic given that you already know Scientology will not adhere to the terms regardless, but will make a very large and public fuss if you do not.

This one is my favorite: "Foul or abusive language; or Images which actually depict, or which might reasonably be considered to depict, members or leaders of the Church" - there is no assertion that you have engaged in "foul or abusive" behavior. Further, leaders of the "church" would, in the US, be considered public figures and therefore not subject to the same protections as private citizens. Not sure about the law in the UK but if it is at all similar to the US, this clause is asking you to *voluntarily* waive your right to parody or even name the figureheads of this organization. (What good is a protest if the Captain Davy doll can't come?)

Then there is this: "We are describing this list as a 'voluntary code of conduct' as it is intended to ensure that all stakeholders at the site act in a lawful and peaceful fashion, and in a manner which balances the competing interests of the Church, its members, local residents and protesters." Firstly, there is no evidence that this has not already been adhered to by the protestors. Secondly, the permits or permission you have sought from local law enforcement would already cover this (and most of what is in this 'voluntary' agreement). Thirdly, it is not your responsibility (nor, truly, that of these elected officials) to "balance the competing interest of the Church." The only duty of these elected officials is to uphold the law, not to ensure that one constituent (the "Church") is not inconvenienced at the expense of the rights of the protestors.

My take on this is that these elected officials are backed into a corner and looking for an easy way out - asking you to "voluntarily" waive your rights and adhere to guidelines to make one (albeit very powerful) constituent happy at the expense of all their other constituents. Having worked with elected officials for decades, I would bet that these folks are holding their breath, with all fingers and toes crossed, that you will see this as innocuous and agree. The wording of this sounds very much to me like they know that they cannot legally approve the PSPO and are desperately looking for a way to mollify Scientology without having to deny the PSPO outright.

My suggestion would be to make a counter-proposal: all parties will abide by the laws applicable to a protest of this type. You get the permits/permissions you need from local law enforcement and those will cover any additional provisions (as in: no amplified sound, etc) without you being required to "voluntarily" waive your rights in advance. Offer to post the currently applicable laws to your website in addition to the terms of the permit/permission once you receive it. It will be essentially the same as what they are asking you to do here - without the insidious consequence of you "voluntarily" waiving some aspects of your right to protest or Scientology being able to claim that you violated the terms that you "voluntarily" agreed to.

Wishing you the best of luck from the US!

11 more comments...

Ready for more?