Alex Barnes-Ross has another important update for us regarding the future of protests at Scientology’s UK headquarters…
As many of you know, last year Scientology filed for a Public Spaces Protection Order (PSPO), which would effectively ban protesting outside Saint Hill, their UK headquarters. Since their application was made, we have been embroiled in a lengthy process during which protestors, local residents and Scientology event attendees were asked to provide their thoughts on whether a ban is necessary.
At the protest outside Scientology’s annual IAS (International Association of Scientologists) gala last year, Mid-Sussex District Council (MSDC) observers were present to observe our activities, and since then they have been carefully reviewing all the evidence gathered — including liaison with Sussex Police, the West Sussex County Council (WSCC) Highways authority and other key stakeholders. On 10th April, I and a handful of others met with the Council to present our case and answer questions about our demonstration and shortly after, a similar meeting was held between the Council and Scientology’s representatives.
In order for a PSPO to be implemented, there needs to be clear evidence of “persistent, ongoing disruption” (such as anti-social behaviour) that existing Police powers are not sufficient enough to deal with. The case we presented to the Council argues that in the last six years, there have only been two protests outside Saint Hill and at both events, Police were present across all three days and there have been no arrests, cautions or warnings. The protests were both peaceful, and steps were taken to mitigate any potential disruption to local residents and event attendees.
After carefully reviewing the evidence and hearing arguments from both sides, Mid-Sussex District Council have asked us to consider implementing a ‘voluntary code of conduct’, which requires agreement from both protestors and Scientology. This has not been presented as an alternative to a PSPO, but our response will be considered as part of the decision-making process, and will impact their assessment on whether a PSPO is necessary.
Based on our response, Council Officers will produce a report with their recommendations for elected officials to vote on. If they decide to go ahead, the next steps will involve a wider public consultation period, equalities impact assessments and further scrutiny, with the alternative being that no PSPO is necessary and therefore no additional restrictions being put in place.
I wanted to share the latest letter from the Council with The Underground Bunker to ask for readers’ feedback and comments on the proposed ‘voluntary code’, which will be used to inform my response on behalf of our community. So please, leave your comments below!
— Alex Barnes-Ross
Dear Protester,
Re: Meeting at Mid-Sussex District Council 10th April 2025.
Application by Church of Scientology for a Public Spaces Protection Order (PSPO) on Saint Hill Road and West Hoathly Road, East Grinstead.
Thank you for meeting with Council officers on the 10th April 2025 to discuss the application by the Church of Scientology (the Church) for a PSPO on Saint Hill Road and West Hoathly Road, East Grinstead. I attach the notes taken of the meeting again for completeness.
As you know, Council staff have also met with representatives of the Church to discuss their application for a PSPO on Saint Hill Road and West Hoathly Road, East Grinstead.
The Council have considered responses from both the Church and Protesters and from Sussex Police, West Sussex Highways Authority and residents of East Grinstead. The Council have made early observations about what parties have said. It appears that a reasonable and proportionate approach in the first instance is to invite the Church and Protesters to mutually and voluntarily agree to comply with a list of obligations and behaviours surrounding Saint Hill Road and West Hoathly Road particularly in relation to the annual International Association of Scientology (IAS) event. We are describing this list as a “voluntary code of conduct” as it is intended to ensure that all stakeholders at the site act in a lawful and peaceful fashion, and in a manner which balances the competing interests of the Church, its members, local residents and protesters.
The Council accepts that some of these items already appear on your protest website (iasprotest.com ), and/or reflect protesters’ practices during recent events at Church premises. It therefore hopes they will be uncontroversial.
Protesters’ response to this request will assist the Council in making a recommendation on agreeing or not agreeing to a PSPO.
Voluntary Code of Conduct for Protesters at Saint Hill Road:
Whilst protesting on Saint Hill Road, protesters will follow and comply with any instructions given by the police and/or any officers of MSDC or WSCC.
At all times protesters will remain in a space designated for their use in agreement with the police, other than for the reasonable purposes of entering and exiting that space.
At all times protesters will remain on public land or the public highway. In particular they will not enter (or attempt to enter) the property of the Church at any time.
Protesters will not obstruct (or attempt to obstruct) any persons from entering Church premises.
Protesters will not (or will not attempt to) harass, intimidate or abuse any persons attending events at Church premises, or persons providing security or stewarding services for Church events. This includes using foul or abusive language.
Protesters will not display images, text, banners, placards, posters or similar which include:
Foul or abusive language; or Images which actually depict, or which might reasonably be considered to depict, members or leaders of the Church
Protesters will not play or use amplified music, voice or audio.
Protesters will not film or photograph any persons entering or exiting Church premises.
Protesters will not approach persons entering or exiting Church premises with leaflets or similar
Protesters shall display this Voluntary Code of Conduct on their website and shall ensure that copies are available for any persons attending as protesters during any events at Saint Hill Road.
For your information, we are also inviting the Church to agree to comply with a corresponding Voluntary Code of Conduct for the Church, which is proposed as follows:
The Church (its staff, volunteers, agents and/or contractors) shall follow and comply with any instructions given by the police and/or any officers of MSDC or WSCC.
The Church shall ensure that persons providing stewarding or security services in and around its property are identifiable to members of the public by wearing high-vis jackets, armbands or similar.
The Church shall provide adequate lighting at the entrance to its premises on Saint Hill Road to ensure the safety of pedestrians and vehicles entering or exiting its premises from the public highway. The adequacy of lighting should be agreed with the police and MSDC in advance of an event (and/or the same lighting may be provided if previously agreed).
The Church (its staff, volunteers, agents and/or contractors) shall not attempt to enter or interfere with a space designated by the police for use by protesters whilst protesters are present within that space.
The Church (its staff, volunteers, agents and/or contractors) shall not obstruct (or attempt to obstruct) protesters from entering or exiting the area designated for their use.
The Church shall not play or use amplified music, voice or audio except at designated times agreed in advance with MSDC and the police and shall comply with the requirements of the Licensing Act 2003 and the premises license issued by MSDC namely, a Noise Management Plan will be submitted to the Licensing Authority for all licensable activities at the premises. It will be reviewed annually and if necessary, during its term, as required. It must be submitted to the Licensing Authority on or before the anniversary of the issue (2nd August) of the License.
The Church (including but not limited to its staff, volunteers, agents and/or contractors) shall not film or photograph protesters who remain within the space designated by the police for their use.
The Church (including but not limited to its staff, volunteers, agents and/or contractors) shall comply with the requirements of the Licensing Act 2003 and the premises license issued by MSDC — namely, you are required to notify the relevant health and safety enforcing authority of all upcoming events to be held within the grounds of Saint Hill Manor, 6 weeks prior to the actual event occurring detailing the nature of the event and any activities carried out on site.
The Church shall ensure that printed and laminated copies of both Voluntary Codes of Conduct are displayed in locations on or visible from the public highway in and around the entrance(s) to Church property and the designated protest space, during Church events at which protesters are expected to attend.
I would be grateful if you can confirm receipt of this email and confirm whether you and your fellow protesters would be willing to agree to comply with this suggested list. If not, we would welcome any further comments or suggestions you would like to provide within 7 days receipt of this letter.
Yours sincerely
Lucy Corrie
Assistant Director Communities
Mid Sussex District Council
A special treat for our subscribers
Today subscribers will receive Episode 118 of our special podcast series, “Group Therapy.”
We discuss the week’s revelations with our gang of jokers and degraders, including Patty Moher, and our transoceanic friend Alex Barnes-Ross!
It’s all the enturbulation you could want!
We’re offering this series as thanks to our subscribers for helping to support the work we do here at the Underground Bunker.
Want to help?
Please consider joining the Underground Bunker as a paid subscriber. Your $7 a month will go a long way to helping this news project stay independent, and you’ll get access to our special material for subscribers. Or, you can support the Underground Bunker with a Paypal contribution to bunkerfund@tonyortega.org, an account administered by the Bunker’s attorney, Scott Pilutik. And by request, this is our Venmo link, and for Zelle, please use (tonyo94 AT gmail). E-mail tips to tonyo94@gmail.com. Find us at Threads: tony.ortega.1044 and Bluesky: @tonyortega.bsky.social
For the full picture of what’s happening today in the world of Scientology, please join the conversation at tonyortega.org, where we’ve been reporting daily on David Miscavige’s cabal since 2012. There you’ll find additional stories, and our popular regular daily features:
Source Code: Actual things founder L. Ron Hubbard said on this date in history
Avast, Ye Mateys: Snapshots from Scientology’s years at sea
Overheard in the Freezone: Indie Hubbardism, one thought at a time
Past is Prologue: From this week in history at alt.religion.scientology
Random Howdy: Your daily dose of the Captain
Here’s the link for today’s post at tonyortega.org
And whatever you do, subscribe to this Substack so you get our breaking stories and daily features right to your email inbox every morning.
Paid subscribers get access to a special podcast series…
Group Therapy: Our round table of rowdy regulars on the week’s news



I have visited Great Britain and plan to return there. I was member of Scientology for almost 50 years.
While in the UK I would if my schedule permits participate in a protest and follow the guidelines set out by the protesters and council.
The protests are necessary to expose the continued abuse by the church of its staff and unfounded attacks and defamation of ex-members and social media reporters exposing the crimes of the church of Scientology.
Hi Alex - I have worked in politics in the US for many years and although I am unfamiliar with free speech laws in the UK, there are a few points I would raise for your consideration:
Acceptance of this 'voluntary code of conduct' implies that you are conceding that there has been some type of misconduct on the part of the protestors that needs to be prevented, despite the assertion here that you have adhered to many of these guidelines already. ("The Council accepts that some of these items already appear on your protest website (iasprotest.com ), and/or reflect protesters’ practices during recent events at Church premises.")
The notion of requiring you to adhere to a "voluntary" code of conduct is counterintuitive and would be unenforceable. It's voluntary, not required. And extremely problematic given that you already know Scientology will not adhere to the terms regardless, but will make a very large and public fuss if you do not.
This one is my favorite: "Foul or abusive language; or Images which actually depict, or which might reasonably be considered to depict, members or leaders of the Church" - there is no assertion that you have engaged in "foul or abusive" behavior. Further, leaders of the "church" would, in the US, be considered public figures and therefore not subject to the same protections as private citizens. Not sure about the law in the UK but if it is at all similar to the US, this clause is asking you to *voluntarily* waive your right to parody or even name the figureheads of this organization. (What good is a protest if the Captain Davy doll can't come?)
Then there is this: "We are describing this list as a 'voluntary code of conduct' as it is intended to ensure that all stakeholders at the site act in a lawful and peaceful fashion, and in a manner which balances the competing interests of the Church, its members, local residents and protesters." Firstly, there is no evidence that this has not already been adhered to by the protestors. Secondly, the permits or permission you have sought from local law enforcement would already cover this (and most of what is in this 'voluntary' agreement). Thirdly, it is not your responsibility (nor, truly, that of these elected officials) to "balance the competing interest of the Church." The only duty of these elected officials is to uphold the law, not to ensure that one constituent (the "Church") is not inconvenienced at the expense of the rights of the protestors.
My take on this is that these elected officials are backed into a corner and looking for an easy way out - asking you to "voluntarily" waive your rights and adhere to guidelines to make one (albeit very powerful) constituent happy at the expense of all their other constituents. Having worked with elected officials for decades, I would bet that these folks are holding their breath, with all fingers and toes crossed, that you will see this as innocuous and agree. The wording of this sounds very much to me like they know that they cannot legally approve the PSPO and are desperately looking for a way to mollify Scientology without having to deny the PSPO outright.
My suggestion would be to make a counter-proposal: all parties will abide by the laws applicable to a protest of this type. You get the permits/permissions you need from local law enforcement and those will cover any additional provisions (as in: no amplified sound, etc) without you being required to "voluntarily" waive your rights in advance. Offer to post the currently applicable laws to your website in addition to the terms of the permit/permission once you receive it. It will be essentially the same as what they are asking you to do here - without the insidious consequence of you "voluntarily" waiving some aspects of your right to protest or Scientology being able to claim that you violated the terms that you "voluntarily" agreed to.
Wishing you the best of luck from the US!